A normal day at a Georgia thrift store turned extraordinary when a clerk spotted a shiny coin while counting change. The coin looked unusual — a 1999 Susan B. Anthony dollar. Curious, she took it to a local coin expert, who confirmed it was a rare 1999-P proof-like Susan B. Anthony dollar.
Weeks later, the coin sold for $4,200 at an auction in Atlanta, sparking nationwide excitement among coin collectors.
Why the 1999-P Susan B. Anthony Dollar Is Rare
The Susan B. Anthony dollar was minted from 1979 to 1981 and briefly in 1999. While most of these coins are common, the 1999-P proof-like version is extremely rare.
Key Features:
- Minted in Philadelphia (“P” mint mark)
- Proof-like surface with a mirror finish
- Made primarily for collectors
- Very limited number known to exist
Coins in perfect proof-like condition can fetch as much as $10,000 at auction.
The $4,200 Auction Story
At the Atlanta auction, bidding began at $1,000. Within minutes, collectors drove the price to $4,200. The winning bidder, a Texas collector, called it a “dream find.”
For the thrift store clerk, the discovery was life-changing. She used the money to pay off student loans and start saving for a car — all thanks to one small coin.
How to Tell If You Have a Valuable 1999-P Dollar
Finding one of these rare dollars is possible. Here’s what to check:
- Date & Mint Mark: 1999 with a “P”
- Surface: Mirror-like, reflective shine
- Errors: Look for doubled letters or misaligned details
- Condition: Minimal scratches, sharp design features
Coin Collecting Tip: Don’t Ignore Your Pocket Change
Because of its size, the Susan B. Anthony dollar is often mistaken for a quarter. But with its unique silver tone and bold design, it stands out once you look closely.
Collectors suggest checking pocket change, coin jars, and thrift store tills. Rare coins still show up in everyday transactions — sometimes worth thousands of dollars.
Final Thoughts
The Georgia thrift store discovery proves that rare coins are still out there waiting to be found. If you spot a 1999-P Susan B. Anthony dollar with a proof-like shine, don’t dismiss it as ordinary pocket change — it could be your ticket to a collector’s payday.